Tony Faust's Oyster House and Restaurant, Northeast corner of Broadway and Elm Street, St. Louis
← Picture This STL
commercial·demolished

Tony Faust's Oyster House and Restaurant

Originally Tony Faust's Oyster House and Saloon
Also known as Faust's Restaurant
Also known as Fulton Market
1889 – 1933
Updated November 2026
About

A two-story corner building, its fronts on Broadway and Elm run as a continuous gallery of tall windows behind an ornamental balcony railing at the second floor, with striped awnings shading the ground floor. The corner was rounded and carried up into a domed cupola, and finials stood along the roofline. The main entrance sat at the corner under a sign reading FAUST.

History

Anthony E. Faust came to New York from Germany in 1853 at seventeen and settled in St. Louis, where he opened a café on Carondelet Avenue after an injury ended his work as a plasterer. In 1870 he moved north to the northeast corner of Broadway and Elm, beside the Southern Hotel, and opened Tony Faust's Oyster House and Saloon on property he leased from the hotel's owner. The 1877 fire that destroyed the hotel badly damaged the restaurant; Faust rebuilt it and reopened on July 4, 1877. In 1879 he added a roof garden of about 60 by 100 feet, and in 1880 he opened the Fulton Market, selling fish, game, produce and cheese, beneath the rebuilt hotel. He opened a new building on the corner in 1889, after studying restaurants and kitchens in Europe. It was reputedly the first restaurant in St. Louis lit by electricity. Faust's was the city's best-known restaurant for decades. Actors crossed over from the Olympic Theatre after performances, and Adolphus Busch lunched there almost daily with other businessmen at the "Millionaires' Table." The two were close friends, and Faust's son Edward married Busch's daughter Anna Louise. Faust died in 1906 after a carriage accident in Germany. His former chef Henry Dietz bought the business in 1915, and the restaurant closed on June 30, 1916. The building was torn down in 1933 with the Southern Hotel. The Stadium East garage now covers the site.

Last stood at
Northeast corner of Broadway (Fifth Street) and Elm Street, St. Louis, MO 63102
Location
Historical Images · 3
Tony Faust's Oyster House and Restaurant: The last Faust building, at the northeast corner of Broadway and Elm, with its corner cupola and the FAUST sign over the entrance.
The last Faust building, at the northeast corner of Broadway and Elm, with its corner cupola and the FAUST sign over the entrance.
after 1889
Missouri Historical Society · Richard Fuhrmann Collection
Tony Faust's Oyster House and Restaurant: The 1908 Sanborn map: Tony Faust saloon and restaurant at the southwest corner of the Southern Hotel block, Broadway (left) and Elm (bottom).
The 1908 Sanborn map: Tony Faust saloon and restaurant at the southwest corner of the Southern Hotel block, Broadway (left) and Elm (bottom).
1908
Library of Congress · Sanborn Fire Insurance Maps, St. Louis 1908, vol. 1, sheet 18
Tony Faust's Oyster House and Restaurant: Anthony E. "Tony" Faust, studio portrait by J. C. Strauss.
Anthony E. "Tony" Faust, studio portrait by J. C. Strauss.
late 19th century
Missouri Historical Society · Missouri Historical Society Photographs and Prints
Further Reading
Tony Faust's
Lost Tables · website
↗
100 years gone, Tony Faust's Oyster House still sets the bar high for St. Louis dining
St. Louis Public Radio · article
↗
A fond look back at Adolphus Busch's go-to lunch spot
St. Louis Magazine · article
↗
Faust Restaurant, northeast corner of Broadway and Elm Street, P0764-00291-4g
Missouri Historical Society · archive
↗
Tony Faust's Oyster House and Restaurant · Picture This STL