Lynch's Slave Pen (Fifth and Myrtle), Northeast corner of Fifth and Myrtle streets, St. Louis
← Picture This STL
commercial·demolished

Lynch's Slave Pen (Fifth and Myrtle)

Formerly Myrtle Street Prison
ca. 1859 – 1963
Updated November 2026
About

No photograph of the pen building is known. What survived into the 1960s were four cells in the basement of a later warehouse on the corner, with brick and stone walls and no windows, light, ventilation or sanitary facilities.

History

Bernard M. Lynch, St. Louis's leading slave trader, outgrew his pen on Locust Street and bought a building at the northeast corner of Fifth and Myrtle streets in 1859, opening his last and largest slave pen there by 1860. Enslaved people were held there for sale, many of them shipped down the Mississippi to markets in Memphis, Natchez and New Orleans. Galusha Anderson, pastor of Second Baptist Church, saw children from about five to sixteen years old held for sale at the corner of Fifth and Myrtle, and watched a girl of about sixteen sold at auction. When the Civil War began Lynch fled to Louisiana. In September 1861 the Union army seized the pen, and it became the Myrtle Street Prison, holding Confederate soldiers, civilians accused of supporting the Confederacy, and Union soldiers. Lynch's oak cash box was recovered from his office when the army took the building. The Meyer Brothers Drug Company later covered the block between Fifth (Broadway) and Fourth, Elm and Clark, with warehouses. Four of the pen's cells survived in a basement there until February 1963, when the Post-Dispatch reported them; the buildings were torn down that year for the downtown Busch Stadium and its garages. A marker placed by the Chamber of Commerce's Young Men's Division was lost in the demolition and never replaced. In 2026 a bronze plaque was installed on the Stadium East garage at Broadway and Clark, after a five-year effort begun by state representatives Trish Gunby and Rasheen Aldridge Jr.

Last stood at
Northeast corner of Fifth and Myrtle streets (now Broadway and Clark Ave), site of the Stadium East garage, 300 S. Broadway, St. Louis, MO 63102
Location
Historical Images · 3
Lynch's Slave Pen (Fifth and Myrtle): The block in 1908, filled by the Meyer Brothers Drug Company. The pen stood at the lower left, the northeast corner of Broadway (formerly Fifth) and Clark (formerly Myrtle), where the shipping and packing warehouse appears.
The block in 1908, filled by the Meyer Brothers Drug Company. The pen stood at the lower left, the northeast corner of Broadway (formerly Fifth) and Clark (formerly Myrtle), where the shipping and packing warehouse appears.
1908
Library of Congress · Sanborn Fire Insurance Maps, St. Louis 1908, vol. 1, sheet 18
Lynch's Slave Pen (Fifth and Myrtle): Bernard M. Lynch's oak cash box, recovered from his office at the pen when federal authorities took it over in September 1861.
Bernard M. Lynch's oak cash box, recovered from his office at the pen when federal authorities took it over in September 1861.
1850–1861
Missouri Historical Society · Missouri Historical Society Collections
Lynch's Slave Pen (Fifth and Myrtle): Demolition of the Meyer Brothers Drug Company buildings at Fourth and Clark, June 24, 1963, the year the surviving cells were lost.
Demolition of the Meyer Brothers Drug Company buildings at Fourth and Clark, June 24, 1963, the year the surviving cells were lost.
1963-06-24
Missouri Historical Society · Sievers Studio Collection
Further Reading
Lynch's Slave Pen historical marker
HMdb · website
↗
The Story of a Border City During the Civil War (Galusha Anderson, 1908)
Project Gutenberg · book
↗
A push to mark the buried history of harrowing slave prisons near Busch Stadium
St. Louis Public Radio · article
↗
New plaque will mark notorious St. Louis slave prison site near Busch Stadium
St. Louis Public Radio · article
↗
Oak Cash Box from Office of Slave Trader Bernard M. Lynch, 1915-043-0001
Missouri Historical Society · archive
↗
Lynch's slave pen
Wikipedia · website
↗
The Slave Trade in St. Louis
National Park Service · website
↗